Pass over this haggadah: Messianic seder kit sparks concern among Jews

Here’s a Passover riddle: When is a haggadah not Jewish?

Answer: When it’s got more Jesus than a matzah has holes.

A Jewish anti-missionary group has succeeded in persuading several booksellers to reclassify a Passover guide from a “messianic Jewish” publisher as Christian, rather than Jewish. As of press time, the guide also had been removed from the online stores for Barnes & Noble and Wal-Mart. still had a page for the book, but it was listed as “out of print.”

If you judge a book by its cover, the “Passover Family Pack: Everything You Need to Enjoy a Passover Seder Dinner” looks like a traditional holiday starter kit. A festive drawing adorns the front of the package, which includes a seder plate, a Kiddush cup, two copies of the haggadah and a cassette tape of music, all for $39.99.

Rabbi Tovia Singer

But a few pages into the haggadah it becomes clear that something is fishy — and it’s not the gefilte. The guide recasts the story of Passover as a mere setup for the arrival of “Yeshua the Messiah”: The text says the wine represents the blood of Jesus, the matzah represents his body, the three matzahs represent the Christian Holy Trinity, and so on.

“They’re taking the traditions of the Jewish faith and using them as a blunt instrument to convert Jewish people to the Christian faith,” said Rabbi Tovia Singer, director of the anti-missionary group Outreach Judaism and host of a radio talk show in Jerusalem. “It’s a paradigm of this entire nefarious movement. They use subterfuge to lure Jews who would normally resist a more straightforward evangelical message.”

The publisher of the “Passover Family Pack” says he’s not trying to trick Jews into worshipping Jesus.

“That would be a terrible thing,” said Barry Rubin, author of the haggadah contained in the Passover kit and president and CEO of Messianic Jewish Communications, a division of distributor Messianic Jewish Resources International. He notes that the cover of the kit identifies the haggadah as messianic — which it does, in small letters below a larger Hebrew title.

“It looks like a regular seder kit because it is … There’s nothing deceptive at all about it,” said Rubin, who is the rabbi of Emmanuel Messianic Jewish Congreg-ation in Maryland.

Rubin said he doesn’t think the Passover kit should be classified as Christian, as he considers himself a Jew. He thinks a good compromise would be for booksellers to establish a “Messianic Jewish” section of their stores.

When Singer complained to Barnes & Noble about stocking the messianic material in the Jewish section, the retailer quickly apologized and reclassified the kit as Christian. It was later removed from the site.

“When it was brought to our attention, we immediately changed it.”

A petition on the Web site asking booksellers to reclassify the kit has garnered more than 2,000 signatures. And concerned Jews have taken matters into their own hands by posting negative reviews on

“Understand that this is NOT by Jews, for Jews — it is by an organization that tries to convert Jews by telling them that you can believe in Jesus and still be Jewish. It’s a TRAP!!!” Albert Passy wrote in his review. “Why don’t they call it ‘Passover With Jews for Jesus’?”

Reached at his home in Houston, Passy said that he had received a warning about the book via e-mail and was dismayed to find that all the reviews on were positive.

“I know the power of Amazon reviews, so I wanted to lend some weight to the negative aspect,” he said. “I’ve met a lot of Jews who are fairly unconnected with their faith, and I always worry about proselytizing things like this, because they’re just insidious.”

It’s unclear whether any unaware Jew has actually bought the “Passover Family Pack” and been disappointed (or converted) by it. One reviewer picked it up for free from a box of discarded books, hoping to add it to the family’s haggadah collection. “We ended up recycling it once we saw it was a missionizing screed that pretended to be a haggadah,” reviewer S. Norman wrote. “We thought, ‘Who wants to celebrate our deliverance from [Egypt] by reading something that wants to re-enslave us!’ ”

Though this particular haggadah is unlikely to inspire many practicing Jews to convert, Singer says the missionaries’ bait-and-switch technique often works, especially on vulnerable populations such as college students and lonely elderly people.

Singer adds that efforts by far-right Christian churches to convert Jews erode the otherwise good progress of interfaith relations: “It’s toxic to Jewish-Christian relations.”

Rubin disagrees, noting that many of the hundreds of thousands of copies of his messianic haggadah have gone to church groups that genuinely want to learn more about Jewish traditions.

“We’re not ashamed of what we publish,” Rubin said. “We think it has helped tens of thousands of Christians appreciate Jewish people, and I don’t see how that could be a problem.”

This article was reprinted with permission from the Jewish Daily Forward.