My name is Nancy — and that is the point of this story.

When my husband, Stan, and I got married in August 1967, we received a wedding gift from a couple who were almost strangers; Stan knew them only slightly, and I had met them once or twice. The gift itself — a copper pitcher — was fairly ordinary, but the note that accompanied it was truly bizarre, given the superficial nature of our relationship.

“You are our dearest friends,” it said; “we will miss you so much” (we were leaving New York to attend graduate school); “you are very important in our lives.”

Lovely sentiments all, but highly inappropriate considering how little they knew us.

The following December, we received a holiday card from this couple to whom we meant so much. On the card, handwritten above the printed message, was: “Dear Stan and Sue.” Four months after being so important in their lives, they couldn’t get my name right.

Ah, how quickly they forget…I sometimes wonder who Sue is, and I really would love to know who was meant to get that copper pitcher.

J. covers our community better than any other source and provides news you can't find elsewhere. Support local Jewish journalism and give to J. today. Your donation will help J. survive and thrive!