Was MacFarlanes Oscar performance bigoted, or funny: Host was mocking stereotypes

Sign up for Weekday J and get the latest on what's happening in the Jewish Bay Area.

No one sends out press releases to announce that something is not anti-Semitic. That’s why this week’s media was full of reports that host Seth MacFarlane’s Oscar performance was just shy of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad’s U.N. speech.

The Anti-Defamation League was first out of the gate, calling MacFarlane “offensive and not remotely funny” — which in and of itself is funny, the idea that the ADL is not just the arbiter of anti-Semitism but of humor.

Then came a press release from the Simon Wiesenthal Center, seeing the ADL’s umbrage and raising it to world historic levels.

“It is unfortunate that at a time when anti-Semitism is so prevalent throughout the world that Seth MacFarlane used the pulpit of the Oscars, before an audience of more than a billion people, to contribute to the myth that Jews own Hollywood.”

I found these reactions more annoying than MacFarlane’s comments, which varied from the very funny to the remotely funny, but never came close to anti-Semitism.

Seth MacFarlane was joking. He was poking fun. He was mocking the widespread understanding that Jews are disproportionately represented in the entertainment business. This fact comes as a shock to exactly no one, and the idea that joking about it “feeds” anti-Semitism misunderstands both the nature of humor and of anti-Semitism.

One thing humor does well, even better than press releases, is diffuse prejudice. It does that through mockery, exaggeration and sometimes by just bringing prejudice to light. That explains everything from Charlie Chaplin in “The Great Dictator” to Sacha Baron Cohen’s character of Borat, who got dozens of Arizonans at a rodeo to sing the “famous” folk song from Kazakhstan, “Throw the Jew Down the Well.” Cohen wasn’t out to whip up Jew hatred, he was out to expose human — hmm, what’s the word? — stupidity.

MacFarlane doesn’t really believe you have to change your name or give to Israel to make it in Hollywood; he was riffing on the simplistic belief that that’s all it takes.

Billy Crystal could make a dozen Jewish references at the Oscars and no one would do anything but kvell. Granted, MacFarlane’s humor is more in-your-face — but it goes nowhere that Crystal, or Adam Sandler in his “Chanukah Song,” or Lenny Bruce in his Jewish/gentile rift, or a hundred other comedians, haven’t gone before.

So why the outrage? Maybe because against the backdrop of increasing anti-Semitism in Europe and elsewhere, Jews are extra sensitive. Maybe because an older generation of Jews is unfamiliar with a newer brand of “Family Guy”/“South Park” humor. Even Amy Davidson, writing on the New Yorker blog, took offense — this from a magazine whose editor David Remnick once wrote a much-deserved, flattering profile of Howard Stern. Stern’s brand of satire paved the way for comedians like MacFarlane.

Or maybe the outrage arises because Jews are still uncomfortable with the notion of being powerful. Deal with it. Jews are disproportionately represented in Hollywood.

But wait, there’s more: The Jewish state has 200 nuclear weapons and a hegemony of power in the Middle East. Jews are disproportionately represented in government, finance, law, publishing and medicine. Only Jews can read these factual statements and think, oy!

The ADL and the Simon Wiesenthal Center not only miss the point, they are missing the opportunity. MacFarlane’s jokes, like all good humor, can get people thinking, can open a conversation: Why are Jews so prevalent in Hollywood? How does their Jewish identity inform their creative choices? How would Hollywood look if it were composed, disproportionately, of WASPs or Thais, or anti-Semites?

Hollywood is one of America’s greatest gifts to the world — why else would 2 billion people tune in to see “Lincoln” get robbed of best picture? There is nothing to hide and plenty to joke about.

Rob Eshman is publisher and editor-in-chief of the Jewish Journal of Greater Los Angeles. You can follow him on Twitter at @foodaism.

Rob Eshman
Rob Eshman

Rob Eshman is a senior columnist for the Forward. Follow him on Instagram @foodaism and Twitter @foodaism or email [email protected].