• News
    • News
    • Bay Area
    • U.S.
    • Israel
    • World
  • Culture
    • TV & Film
    • Books
    • Music
    • Art
    • On Stage
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Letters
    • Editorials
  • Jewish Life
    • Jewish Life
    • Community
    • Lifecycles
    • Obituaries
    • Food
    • Religion
    • Education
    • Kids & Family
    • Seniors
    • Philanthropy
  • Calendar
  • Donate
    • Newsletter
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
  • Subscribe to our Newsletter

      • Archives
      • Readers’ Choice 2022
      • Jewish Resource Guide
      • Subscribe
        • Subscribe to J. Print
        • Sign up for newsletters from J.
        • Renew Subscription
      • Contact
        • Contact J.
        • Change of address
        • Renew Subscription
        • Advertise

      The Jewish News

      of Northern California

      • Readers’ Choice 2022
      • Subscribe
        • Subscribe to J. — in Print
        • Change of address
        • Renew Subscription
        • Sign up for newsletters from J.
      • Contact
      • About
      • News
        • Bay Area
        • U.S.
        • Israel
        • World
      • Culture
        • TV & Film
        • Books
        • Music
        • Art
        • On Stage
      • Opinion
        • Opinion
        • Columns
        • Letters
      • Jewish Life
        • Community
        • Lifecycles
        • Obituaries
        • Food
        • Religion
        • Education
        • Kids & Family
        • Seniors
        • Philanthropy
      • Calendar
      • Archives
      • Jewish Resource Guide
      • DONATE
        • Donors
      • Newsletter
      • Facebook
      • Twitter
      • Instagram
      An interviewee in "Final Account." (Photo/Courtesy Focus Features LLC)
      An interviewee in "Final Account." (Photo/Courtesy Focus Features LLC)
      • Culture
      • Film

      Former Nazis give their ‘Final Account’ in new documentary

      • Facebook
      • Twitter
      • Email
      • SMS
      • WhatsApp
      • Share
      By Andrew Lapin, JTA | May 24, 2021

      There is a remarkable scene toward the end of the new documentary “Final Account,” a collection of eyewitness testimonies from elderly Germans and Austrians who remember the Nazi regime (and, to various degrees, were part of it).

      In the sequence, a former Waffen-SS officer sits down with a group of students in the Berlin suburb of Wannsee — the site of the infamous Wannsee Conference, where Nazi officials met in 1942 to map out the parameters of the Final Solution. The officer, Hans Werk, speaks of the tremendous shame he feels for himself and his country to have orchestrated the genocide of 6 million Jews.

      When Werk is challenged by a young German — an anonymous right-winger obsessed with “protecting the Fatherland” and sick of hearing about “shame” from his elders — the former Nazi fires back, recounting Jewish friends and neighbors of his who had assumed they were also part of the Fatherland, until they were marched off to the camps. The true Nazi ideology was not patriotism, he says, but hate.

      “Do not let yourselves be blinded!” he shouts.

      The film, which opened in movie theaters on May 21, itself has the same aim in mind.

      “Final Account” is the result of more than a decade of interviews conducted by British documentarian Luke Holland, who discovered his Jewish heritage as a teenager upon learning that his mother’s family had been murdered in the Holocaust. Holland died last year at 71, after a long battle with cancer, shortly after completing the film; it now lives as his final account, too.

      There is a workmanlike quality to “Final Account,” which is made up almost entirely of contemporary interviews with former Nazis, in German with English subtitles, conducted mostly in cozy apartments and retirement homes.

      Naturally there are many fewer eyewitnesses left alive today than there were four decades ago, when French Jewish filmmaker Claude Lanzmann interviewed scores for his landmark 10-hour documentary “Shoah.”

      Lanzmann could talk to high-ranking SS officers, including some who oversaw the death camps. By contrast, Holland’s interview subjects were largely children or teenagers at the time.

      Many of the anecdotes in Holland’s film revolve around the subjects joining the Hitler Youth as kids or watching their parents support the Nazi party. A few worked at the camps, or the train stations that led prisoners to them, but their own accounts seem to conveniently distance themselves from the actual murders. Some continue to deny the genocide ever took place.

      These occasional denialists feel more like sideshows to the 90-minute film’s main goal — and they might be committing a crime on camera, since both Germany and Austria have outlawed the practice of Holocaust denial.

      By and large, most of the interviews in “Final Account” focus on the language of culpability: when (or if) one’s presence within an evil regime constitutes being a perpetrator of its aims.

      “We didn’t support the party, but we liked the uniform,” one subject says, conjuring the comic images of exuberant Nazi children in “Jojo Rabbit.”

      We didn’t support the party, but we liked the uniform.

      Others remember the odd yet mundane details that allowed them to build an everyday life around the atrocities taking place in their name, like a former nanny who remembers taking her employer’s kids to their local concentration camp — to say “hi” to their mom at her place of work.

      Holland is never seen on camera, but the fluent German speaker occasionally prods his subjects from offscreen to acknowledge their participation in crimes against humanity, much as Joshua Oppenheimer did to architects of the Indonesian genocide in “The Act of Killing.”

      Together, Holland, Oppenheimer and Lanzmann all form an unsettling lineage of Jewish filmmakers who have felt compelled to confront genocide participants face to face on film.

      “Final Account” doesn’t have quite the same revelatory feel as its predecessors in this genre — the film rarely breaks through the surfaces of its subjects’ accounts to dig at whatever their emotional truth might be. Maybe there isn’t any: One of the overarching messages is that populations can follow hateful ideologies blindly, even blandly, if they feel acceptable enough to the masses.

      But there are moments that wrestle with deeper questions.

      he Wannsee scene, in which one generation of German seems incapable of passing on his personal and historical shame to the next, invokes not only the past but also the future of Holocaust memory. Their conversation is in anticipation of a world in which we have no more “final accounts.”

      When that does happen, and there are no more eyewitnesses left, how are we to continue the lessons of “Never Again”? What forms of education and vigilance will keep us from becoming once again “blinded” to the past?

      It’s a question that has haunted the last century of Jewish life — and, by necessity, must also haunt the next.

      J. covers our community better than any other source and provides news you can't find elsewhere. Support local Jewish journalism and give to J. today. Your donation will help J. survive and thrive!
      Support J.

      Andrew Lapin

      Andrew Lapin is the Managing Editor for Local News at the Jewish Telegraphic Agency.

      JTA

      Content distributed by the Jewish Telegraphic Agency news service.

      Tags: Holocaust, documentary, World War II, Nazis, Shoah, Final Account

      Also On J.

      Leo Belman hard at work on his social justice gap year program in Portland.

      Bay Area

      Pandemic high school grads, one year later

      A view through Red Window's titular red window. (Photo/Mark Fiorito-Gamma Nine Photography)

      Organic Epicure

      For this chef, when a door closed, a Red Window opened

      Joe Schneider: “It’s therapeutic for me to create the dough, and seeing that the bread I make makes people happy.”

      Food

      He's braiding exquisite challah for the common good

      The gang assesses a counterfeit "dybbuk box" on the CW series "Nancy Drew." (Screenshot)

      TV

      How TV has embraced dybbuks, golems and other Jewish lore

      Subscribe to our Newsletter

          Most Popular

          • 1‘No Jew Go Away’ scrawled on door at UC Berkeley
          • 2Bomb and gun threats called into two Bay Area Jewish high schools
          • 3Eco-anxious? Here's how Judaism can help us face the climate crisis
          • 4In season 4, ‘Fauda’ has begun asking some hard questions
          • 5I'm struggling, but I will always fight for the Israel I love
          • Readers’ Choice 2022
          • About
          • Contact/Submissions
          • Careers at J.
          • Advertise
          • Subscribe
          • Terms of Use
          • Facebook
          • Twitter
          • Instagram