Walter Ruby
Walter Ruby

Call him naive, but Imam Rauf is a man of peace

Sign up for Weekday J and get the latest on what's happening in the Jewish Bay Area.


NOTE: This is one of our Two Views this week. For the second view,  <Click here>


Over the last few months, I have had a front-row seat to history.

Last May, I spoke at a public hearing of the Manhattan Community Board No. 1 in support of Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf and Daisy Khan, the husband-and-wife team that initiated plans to build a 13-story Islamic community center two blocks north of ground zero.

I was there on behalf of the Foundation for Ethnic Understanding, which has worked with the group Rauf and Khan lead, the American Society for Muslim Advancement, in ongoing efforts to strengthen Muslim-Jewish relations in the United States and around the world.

Walter Ruby

In my testimony at the hearing, I said that since our organizations began cooperating three years ago, I have consistently found both Rauf and Khan to be unequivocally opposed to violence and terrorism and deeply committed to the American values of democracy and pluralism. These are values, Rauf argues in his book, “What’s Right with Islam,” that are intrinsic to Islam as well.

For this reason, our foundation has consistently supported Rauf’s effort to create an Islamic community center in New York that will serve as a high-profile platform from which to articulate that vision of peaceful and pluralistic Islam to Muslims and non-Muslims alike. Months ago, he and his wife told the president of our foundation, Rabbi Marc Schneier, that they hope to create a center for Muslim-Jewish dialogue at the Islamic community center, in cooperation with our foundation and the larger Jewish community.

Over the past three years, Rauf and Khan have taken part in an annual event sponsored by our foundation known as the Weekend of Twinning of Mosques and Synagogues Across North America, during which mosques and synagogues offer one-on-one programs focusing on and celebrating commonalities in our two faith traditions.

From what I have learned, when Rauf set out during the past few years to bring to fruition his decades-old dream of creating an Islamic community center with a strong interfaith component in New York City, he was never much concerned about where the center would be located.

Yet, when a space large enough to fulfill his vision became available two blocks from ground zero, he saw special significance in the site. He argued that building an Islamic community center there dedicated to nonviolence and mutual understanding among faiths would represent a deeply felt gesture of compassion and healing by the Muslims of New York to the entire New York community, including those who lost loved ones on 9/11.

In retrospect, Rauf can justly be accused of naivete for not perceiving that building an Islamic community center so close to ground zero would unleash the kind of firestorm of fear, loathing and anti-Muslim rhetoric that has erupted in recent weeks. From my conversations with him and his wife on the subject of the proposed center going back almost a year, it is clear to me that they never anticipated the kind of political backlash that has occurred.

Together with the American Society for Muslim Advancement and other moderate Muslim organizations, our foundation will continue to nurture a movement of Muslims and Jews committed to communication, reconciliation and cooperation.

Walter Ruby is the Muslim-Jewish relations program officer at the New York–based Foundation for Ethnic Understanding. He wrote this piece for JTA.


NOTE: This is one of Two Views. To read the opposing viewpoint from Rabbi Jeffrey K. Salkin of Georgia, <Click here>