In a few weeks, I will be leading Congregation Emanu-El’s annual 10th-grade trip to New York City. As part of the immersion into that American Jewish nirvana, our group will dine at a Jewish deli — so the kids can experience the joy of pastrami on rye and having the rabbi berate them if they dare ask for mayonnaise.
Given health concerns and changing tastes, Jewish delis are becoming an endangered species. To survive, many have moved upscale, with some charging more than $20 for a single pastrami sandwich.
This process of turning something that was simple and basic into a gourmet item exemplifies how we tend to romanticize parts of our impoverished past. In the past, people would eat cured meat as an inexpensive way of insuring the food was safe to eat (cured meat takes longer to spoil). The same was true of blue jeans, which transitioned from practical clothing for the working man to, oftentimes, an expensive fashion statement. Both jeans and the Jewish deli went from prosaic to cool.
In just a few days, we Jews will engage in the practice of eating a food that has never been cool, but throughout the ages has remained symbolically powerful — matzah.
We eat it for Passover and remember yetziat Mitzrayim, the going out from Egypt. As we hold it up at the seder we will declare, “Ha Lachma Anya di achlu avahatana b’ara d’Mitzrayim. This is the bread of affliction, which our ancestors ate in the land of Egypt.”
Matzah serves as a reminder of our humble beginnings. It is an unleavened bread eaten by an unleavened people; we are charged to remember where we came from and then measure our lives by how we respond to that memory.
I know that many of you will only eat matzah at the seder. As one who does not appreciate its tastelessness, I nonetheless think it is essential that we follow the holiday’s mitzvah to eat this poor person’s food not just at the seder but throughout the entire week of Passover.
To help make that happen, I want to see matzah follow in the footsteps of pastrami and corned beef. I want to up its coolness factor — not with flavors (we certainly don’t need Cheetos flaming-hot matzah), but by reminding ourselves that this simple food is a radical, in-your-face statement of Jewish identity.
Whether you eat shmura matzah (the round, handmade variety) or machine-made matzah, or even gluten-free matzah, you are participating in something cool — a public form of resistance that challenges a society that pushes for conformity.
When you eat matzah outside, it’s like a public mezuzah. Especially for those who don’t wear a kippah, suddenly your colleagues are reminded that, despite your techy T-shirt or business suit, you are different — you are a Jew! And with each taste of this distinctive food, you connect with the central message of Passover: Avadim hayinu, v’atah b’nai horin. We were slaves and now we are free.
The public eating of matzah is a reminder not just to us but to those around us that we are a minority in this country, just 2 percent of the population. And we are still oppressed, even here in America. While anti-Semitism is nowhere near as prevalent here as it is in Europe or the Arab Middle East, where one would hesitate to eat matzah in public, or in Russia, where President Vladimir Putin recently tried to blame Jews for hacking the U.S. elections, it is still present.
There is a reason why Jewish institutions such as Congregation Emanu-El have to pay for guards at the front gate, while the church across the street leaves its doors wide open.
When we American Jews eat matzah in public during Passover, we join with generations throughout Jewish history who have consumed it as an act of resistance. It recalls our oppression and then redemption. Like the hanukkiah in the window and the mezuzah on our doorpost, when we eat matzah in public we call out “Hineni, here I am,” a proud American Jew.
I want you to recall with me that my ancestors were wandering Arameans who went to Egypt and sojourned there. Avadim hayinu — we were slaves. v’atah b’nai horin — but now we assert our freedom, our pride and our determination to stand up against all hate as we embrace the joy of life.
Passover starts this week … be sure to pick up a lot of matzah!
Poor persons food? How do you get there? Poor people can’t afford yeast? That’s what Torah says?
Or was it that we had to leave on a trip and make haste so there wasn’t time to wait hours for the yeast to rise and the bread had to last for weeks because we were going to be on the move? Leavened bread goes bad. And takes up a lot of room.
I know that reform Jews like to rewrite Torah to make Torah fit into their political narrative but its just not so. Jews left Egypt rich taking the wealth of Egypt’s with us. Its traveling food.
There is no commandment to eat matzo in public. In fact the uncircumcised aren’t to share In the peschal sacrifice. And yes we are to remember that we were slaves in egypt but maybe that’s not about anything more than acknowledging that hashem brought us out of slavery through no deed of our own working miracles that we couldn’t. Maybe the point is gratitude toward g*d not making gods out of our own agendas and celebrating our political beliefs putting yourself one the same level as g*d as an arbiter of justice. Maybe if you reread the Torah with actual humility you might see the reminders that we were slaves in Egypt not as a call to lefty action but as a reminder that all we are and that all we have done was not of our doing. It started with hashem and perhaps we shouldn’t be so arrogant.
Maybe just once a year you could get over your self rabbi singer and spend some time doing nothing more than being grateful for what g*d did for us. Maybe focusing on a common starting point for out people. (Believe it or not t wasn’t the ivy league or Poland or lower manhattan) Might actually make your Seder mean something for a change. As opposed to just being another day where your politics and agendas trump everything else.
As for going to ny to immerse oneself in Jewish culture? I don’t get it. There’s this country called Israel where there is actual real Jewish culture not faux Seinfeld Jewish culture. Since your flying all the way from San Francisco what’s another seven hours to tel Aviv. Doesn’t cost that much more and when you get there Everything is cheaper.
Heck you can get kosher (which is the only kind of truly Jewish food) pastrami at the rami levy for 16 shekels per half pound.
Unless you think somehow that the last hundred or so years of Jewish life in the pit stop that is new York is somehow relevant in the four thousand year history of a people.
Declaring one’s Jewish pride? What do you mean? You are either a Jew or you are not. There is nothing to declare.
You’re in luck!! IfNotNow Bay Area is putting on seder spectacle For those desiring opportunities to eat matzah and be Jewish in public !!
Saturday, April 7 @ 1:30 PM – Lake Merritt Amphitheater
https://www.facebook.com/events/1925943257718617/
https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/bf5bf488071c0deb34c8e231fe25c417ec5057387bbd9d4d5d51743c456368cf.jpg