Asaf Orr says transgender youth “have taught me what courage and perseverance look like.” (Photo/Trish Tunney Photography)
Asaf Orr says transgender youth “have taught me what courage and perseverance look like.” (Photo/Trish Tunney Photography)

This lawyer fights for his ‘heroes’ — transgender youth

Name: Asaf Orr
Age: 36
City: San Mateo
Position: Transgender Youth Project staff attorney, NCLR

J.: You describe yourself as a cisgender male — meaning that your gender identity corresponds to your birth sex — and as heterosexual in orientation. How did you come to work for a major organization that advocates and legislates on behalf of the LGBT community, with a special affinity for transgender kids?

Asaf Orr: I went to law school [at Rutgers] knowing that I wanted to focus on LGBT issues, but there were several incidents while I was a high school student in Highland Park, New Jersey, that had a significant impact. I remember when two kids came out in my fairly small high school and the rumor mill was quite vicious. I also worked in a music store owned by an openly gay man. The landlord evicted him because he was gay. He didn’t have the wherewithal to fight and the store closed.

Those experiences clearly made an impression and set you on a path. You joined the National Center for Lesbian Rights in 2012 and became its Transgender Youth Project staff attorney in 2015. But you having been working consistently on behalf of LGBT rights since before your law school graduation. Will you describe some of these experiences?

I interned at Lambda Legal Defense Fund after my first year of law school. Following a clerkship with Judge Virginia Long of the New Jersey Supreme Court, I received the Rainbow Rights Fellowship to the Learning Rights Law Center in Los Angeles, where I used special education laws to advocate on behalf of LGBT students, many of whom were victims of bullying and harassment and had developed phobias and depression as a result. I want to be clear that in applying the special education laws to these students, I am not suggesting that they had particular disabilities in the sense that we often think of when we use the term “special education.” Rather, if you’re going to school every day, there should be a reasonable expectation that there must be services and accommodations in place to ensure an educational environment free of bullying, harassing behaviors.

That’s a pretty interesting application of the law. What sorts of cases do you work on at NCLR?

A lot of our work focuses on schools. A school may have a policy in place to support transgender students, but perhaps the substitute teacher did not get the memo on the use of appropriate pronouns. We also do a lot of work in the area of team sports. Right now, 17 states and the District of Columbia allow kids to participate in sports based on their gender identity. In states without these laws, we have had a lot of success working with state athletic associations to expand access to transgender youth.

These kids are my heroes, and I can’t think of doing anything else.

We have also been involved in custody disputes involving parents where one is affirming of their child’s gender identity and the other is nonaffirming. Access to health care is also an important issue. I had one client who was denied access to puberty-delaying medications. We also provide technical assistance to other groups and organizations without NCLR’s resources, and we file friend-of-the-court briefs in other cases brought on behalf of transgender kids.

What have you learned about transgender youth through your work — and what have they taught you? 

Transgender young people face high levels of family rejection, and there is a higher incidence of substance abuse, homelessness and underemployment among them. Yet working with these young people and their families is amazing. They have taught me what courage and perseverance look like. These kids are my heroes, and I can’t think of doing anything else.

Describe your Jewish background, and how it informs your work and family life.

My parents were born in Israel, where much of my family remains and where I spent many summers. My dad came to the States to go to graduate school at Rutgers. We belonged to a Reform temple there — in New Brunswick— and my family and I were active in many social justice and civic activities. I was involved in Mitzvah Corps groups as a part of NFTY (North American Federation of Temple Youth), and we did work to benefit a local soup kitchen, camp for kids with disabilities and assisted-living community for Jews.

I am a mixture of Ashkenazi and Mizrahi heritages, and my wife, who is an educator at Eastside College Prep [in East Palo Alto], is an Iranian American Jew. Our 9-year-old twins went to Jewish preschool. They now go to a school with a transgender student, and they see every day that she is just like them and entitled to respect.

Why should we all care about transgender rights for children?

We should all care because we want our kids to grow up to be who they are. When they are affirmed for who they are, they thrive. What parent doesn’t want that for his child?

“Talking With” focuses on local Jews who are doing things we find interesting. Send suggestions to [email protected].

Robert Nagler Miller
Robert Nagler Miller

Robert Nagler Miller, a Phi Beta Kappa graduate of Wesleyan University, received his master's degree from Northwestern University's Medill School of Journalism. For more than 25 years, he worked as a writer and editor at a variety of nonprofits in the Los Angeles and Bay Areas. In 2016, he and his husband, Dr. Arnold Friedlander, relocated to Chicago. Robert loves schmoozing, noshing, kvetching, Scrabble, reading and NPR.